Judging Criteria: Smokin’ Hot Heroes Contest
Does Your Hero Steal Hearts?
In this Romance writing contest, our judges will evaluate your fiction-writing skills, as well as your understanding of the commercial Romance formula.
Characterization: (50 Points Possible)
- Has the author created a lovable male protagonist, who exudes sex appeal throughout the scene? (10 points possible)
- Is the Hero’s Alpha/Beta persona consistent and convincing throughout the scene? Alternatively, is the Hero’s Good Boy/Bad Boy persona consistent and convincing throughout the scene? (10 points possible)
- Is the Hero’s scene goal clear, immediate, and concrete? (5 points possible)
- Has the author effectively applied internal conflict and character motivation to make the Hero interesting, complex, and memorable? (10 points possible)
- Has the author revealed the goals, motivations, and conflicts of other characters in the scene? (5 points possible)
- Is sexual tension present throughout the scene between the hero and heroine? (10 points possible)
Dialogue: (15 Points Possible)
- Does the dialogue sparkle with wit, humor, and tasteful innuendo throughout the scene? (10 points possible)
- Does the dialogue deepen the Hero’s characterization? (5 points possible)
Plot: (20 Points Possible)
- Has the author established emotional tension, escalating that tension in a consistent and convincing way between the Hero and the other characters in the scene? (10 points possible)
- Does the Hero tackle obstacles in ways that Romance readers can admire, or at least understand? (10 points possible)
General: (15 Points Possible)
- Did the author follow standard formatting procedure? (A “no” will disqualify the entry.)
- Is the entry free of typos and errors in punctuation and grammar? (3 points possible)
- Is the author’s voice suitable for the Romance subgenre, which was designated on the entry form? (3 points possible)
- Is the scene clearly anchored in time and place? (4 points possible)
- Does the writing come alive? Is the author masterfully balancing “showing” and “telling” language throughout the scene? (5 points possible)